Latest Online Edition  Read Here

Stop Your Sobbing Featured

This piece is, in my opinion, an excellent description of how news stories control their narratives and how while what they may report isn't necessarily fake, it isn't necessarily genuine either. Much depends on what you leave out and how you represent your main character (since, let's be honest, these are stories even if they purport to be true). And that makes me think of this long piece attacking auto finance. It starts out with the story of Aaron Woodrum, a fellow who bought a truck, but couldn't keep it. Part of Aaron's problem is that he was unable to pay a high insurance premium along with his monthly finance payment. The premium, we're told by Aaron, was so high "because it was a financed car." He was paying 25 interest on the contract, so it was so high in part because he had lousy credit.  The article soon leaves poor Aaron to wallow in his misery and and goes on to catalog the alleged evils of the industry. One of the comments, from a guy named ManicDan, responds to other commenters by saying "First few paragraphs are about 1 person, almost every comment is about that same person. I think most commentors have not finished the article yet." Maybe so, Dan, but the author started with the ballad of Aaron Woodrum to set the mood. Once you're sympathetic with Aaron, you will be offended by all the allegations against auto finance. So if people are attacking the entire article based on the main sob story and ignoring the "facts," the author set himself up for this response.   
Rate this item
(0 votes)

Ted Craig

  • Moore or Less
    Actually, the correct phrasing is \\\"Moore or fewer,\\\" as in one fewer Republican Senator. Sometimes candidates blow up on their parties. Anti-establishment candidates carry a higher risk of this happening,…
  • Boxed In
    A recent story in the WSJ details how GM wants to use carbon fiber in its pick-up trucks. Carbon fiber offers the strength of steel with the fuel-saving benefits of…
  • Maybe They're Just Jerks
    A few years ago, a female producer said many men in Hollywood view themselves like this. In reality, they're probably more like this. The recent focus on sexual harassment might…
  • Tax Wins
    The tax bill, as it stands now, seems pretty good for dealers. It keeps the floor plan interest deduction, thanks to Rand Paul. It allows credit unions to continue pretending…
  • What Went Wrong
    A few weeks ago, a former aide to Barney Frank penned an op-ed titled "What Went Wrong with the CFPB." I'll tell you what went wrong. First, the CFPB is…
  • Now You Know
    Education is seen as the answer for everything. The CFPB considers financial literacy the solution to consumers' problems. After the clashes in Charlottesville, there were calls for educating people to…
  • Kinda Disappointed
    It seems the situation concerning CFPB leadership is moving toward a quick resolution, with Leander English unable to stay in the director's office. For a while, I had visions of…
  • Situation Normal
    Starting in 1378, the Catholic Church had two popes. Urban VI was seated in Rome, Clement VII in Avignon, France. Apparently, somebody skipped over the part about two masters. The…
  • Bad News
    The other day, I wrote about the poor coverage of auto sales in the Wall Street Journal. Then, on Friday, I saw another junk article, this one about general retail…
  • No Solutions
    The older I get, the more I'm convinced people don't want solutions. They don't want their problems, but there is a difference between that and solutions. Solutions are hard. They…