Latest Online Edition  Read Here

It's Called a Start-up for a Reason Featured

Everybody is so busy clapping their hands for Carvana's "triple-digit growth" that nobody seems to notice its second biggest increase was its loss, by 122 percent. yes, I know, losses don't matter, look at Amazon, blah blah blah. Also look at Pets.com, Webvan, etc. Whatever. gross profit apparently trumps net loss with the "smart" money on Wall Street.

But despite Carvana's net loss of $38.4 million, the pressure is on companies like CarMax. Many people can't seem to understand why companies like CarMax can't just do what Caravan does. This is the future, after all. Take "investor" and stand-up philosopher Stephen Green. He recently wrote: "Just like Sears did, Radio Shack had the catalog business and associated customer database available to put together a first-rate online business before Amazon sold its first book. Neither company’s management proved innovative enough to do so, and now both are failing." Ah, Greenie, if it were only that simple. Some of these problem comes from managerial stubbornness. But part of it is these companies have other pressures on them. They have rents to pay and pensions to fund. They also have investors who put their money in these companies for reasons other than why they put their money in Amazon and won't put up with the losses Bezos incurred in the early years.

Sometimes it is easier to start from scratch. And sometimes what seems like a brilliant idea, isn't. Only time will tell which category Caravan falls into, disruptor or noise. 

Rate this item
(0 votes)

Ted Craig

  • No Solutions
    The older I get, the more I'm convinced people don't want solutions. They don't want their problems, but there is a difference between that and solutions. Solutions are hard. They…
  • No, They Didn't
    Yesterday's WSJ had an article on plans by Mahindra & Mahindra to start selling vehicles in the U.S. There was no mention that we've seen this show before and it…
  • Breaking Up Isn't Hard to Do
    The latest issue of The Chicago Reader had an article on the divide between downstate Illinois and metropolitan Chicago. The upshot of the article was that downstaters benefit more than…
  • If These Trends Continue...
    My parents owned a copy of Linda Goodman's "Star Signs." Astrology and fortune telling were all the rage in the late '60s and early '70s. Jeane Dixon was a regular…
  • Is Kinder and Gentler Really Better?
    Today's WSJ has an article about the new breed of baseball managers. It says these guys are more concerned about communication than they are about strategy. The days of the…
  • There Oughta Be a Law
    You can make all the laws you want, but there are always two problems with any law. One is how will they be enforced. The other is that criminals, by…
  • Berko the Clown
    This is what Malcolm Berko, an investment columnist, says about Credit Acceptance: "Credit Acceptance Corp. (CACC-$282) has lending contracts with thousands of grubby dealers who run grimy used car lots…
  • Tech and Tariffs
    There are three ways for an American worker to lose a job: they can be replaced by a worker in another country, they can be replaced by a worker from…
  • Taxing Matter
    In his book about the mortgage crisis, Wall Street analyst Barry Ritholtz exonerated the mortgage interest deduction from blame. His reasoning was that the deduction had been around for a…
  • There's a Difference?
    Activists have pushed rules against payday lending that would basically end the practice. They don't like bail bondsmen, either. You might say, "I don't like these people either. What do…